SCBAR
  Login
Journalist and Artist Judging
Background Case Information:  
 
Civil Case
Kelly Simon, Individually, and as the personal representative of the Estate of Jordan Smith, v. Terry Swift, and Hilliard Academy.
 
Jordan Simon was a 17-year old senior in high school who unexpectedly died of a heart attack. He began running at a young age, and had real promise. He joined a well-known private high school, Hilliard Academy’s track team as a freshman, and quickly developed into a star sprinter. At the time of Jordan’s death, he was competing for a track scholarship to an NCAA Division I university. 
 
The autopsy revealed Jordan’s bloodstream contained the steroid Erythropoietin (EPO). EPO is used medically to treat certain forms of anemia. Athletes use EPO to improve performance, because it increases the oxygen-carrying capacity of blood. EPO also increases the blood viscosity, which can cause the blood to clot and clog capillaries, resulting in a heart attack.
 
Kelly Simon, Jordan Simon’s surviving parent, has filed a lawsuit against Hilliard Academy and Terry Swift, the track coach, claiming Hilliard Academy and Terry Swift were negligent in causing Jordan’s death. Specifically, Kelly Simon claims Terry Swift and Hilliard’s athletic department encouraged Jordan to use steroids; should have known he was using steroids; and taken steps to stop his steroid use. 
 
              Terry Swift and Hilliard Academy deny Kelly Simon’s claims, and contend that Jordan Simon assumed the risk of using steroids; and Kelly Simon was comparatively negligent in not discovering Jordan was using steroids, and not taking steps to stop his steroid use. 
 
Names of Witnesses:
Plaintiff Witnesses Defense Witnesses
Kelly Simon                 Plaintiff/Parent Terry Swift       Coach
Morgan Pearce         Teammate/Friend               Jamie Hagar       Asst. Principal/Athletic Director
Lynn Roper, Ph,D. Doctor Aubrey Brady       Athletic Consultant
 
 
Journalist Entries
 
Below are all listed journalist entries.  All entries are to be judged using the same score sheet.  Click Here for the score sheet for journalist scoring.
 

 

Journalist Entry A

 

Journalist Entry B Journalist Entry C

 

Journalist Entry D

 

Journalist Entry E  
 
 
Artist Entries
 
Below are all listed artist entries.  All entries are to be judged using the same score sheet.  Click Here for the score sheet for artist scoring.  Please click on the artwork below to open the full size image.
 
 
     
     
     

 

 

Please fax or email scoresheets by February 27 at noon.

Fax Number: 803-771-0419

E-Mail: ccothran@scbar.org

Any questions about scoring? Contact Cynthia H. Cothran at ccothran@scbar.org, direct (803) 576-3788 or cell (803) 730-1348.

Thank you to everyone for scoring the entries.